Keyhole Surgery for a Meniscal Tear: What the BASK National Guideline Recommended
Key points
- This guideline on keyhole (arthroscopic) surgery for meniscal tears was developed by a working group of the British Association for Surgery of the Knee (BASK) and published in June 2019.
- Urgent surgery was recommended for a locked knee (one that has become stuck and will not fully straighten or bend), and repair was to be considered for a repairable tear after an acute injury.
- For most other patients, at least three months of non-surgical treatment was recommended before surgery was considered.
- Surgery was not recommended for patients with advanced osteoarthritis, except in uncommon special cases.
- We described it as expert surgical opinion that still needed to be validated in clinical practice.
What Is This Guideline?
A meniscus is one of the two pads of cartilage that act as shock absorbers in each knee. Damage to a meniscus is common and does not always cause symptoms. When a tear is thought to be causing symptoms, keyhole surgery to remove the unstable tissue (partial meniscectomy) or to repair it may be recommended.
Trials of partial meniscectomy had been published, but how widely their findings applied was disputed, because they had recruited a broad and inconsistently defined group of patients. My colleagues and I set out to reach a national agreement among surgeons on which patients are candidates for surgery and which for non-surgical treatment. The guideline was written for surgeons and patients in hospital care, and was not designed for use in children.
How Was It Developed?
In November 2016, the BASK research committee and the project's steering committee, of which I was a member, invited 25 surgeons to join the BASK Meniscal Working Group, and 21 took part. The group first agreed how meniscal tears should be defined, investigated and classified, in a national consensus published separately in 2018.
We then applied the RAND/UCLA Appropriateness Method, a validated consensus technique. Members rated 45 simulated patients, prepared from combinations of symptoms and signs, severity of osteoarthritis and MRI findings, on a scale from 1 (surgery inappropriate) to 9 (appropriate). After an anonymous first round, the group met to discuss the results and rated every scenario again. A scenario was classed as appropriate if the median (middle) rating was 7 or above and inappropriate if it was 3 or below, in each case without disagreement. Medians between 4 and 6 were recorded as uncertain. Of the 45 scenarios, 11 (24%) were rated appropriate for surgery, 24 (53%) inappropriate and 10 (22%) uncertain.
The steering committee grouped the scenarios into a draft flow chart. In March 2018 the group discussed it alongside the latest evidence, including a systematic review of the trials and a new analysis of 20 years of national data on the operation's risks, both then unpublished. The draft was then sent to the 195 full active members of BASK who could be surveyed. Of these, 117 (60%) completed the survey, and 113 of them (97%) agreed to practise according to the guideline. The working group approved the final version in September 2018.
The work was supported by a National Institute for Health Research doctoral research fellowship awarded to me and by the Oxford NIHR Biomedical Research Centre. BASK reimbursed members' travel expenses for meetings. No benefits were received from any commercial party.
What Do the Guideline's Terms Mean?
The pathway sorts symptoms and signs into “meniscal”, “possibly meniscal” and arthritic. Those groups, and the terms below, are defined in full in the 2018 consensus linked above. In outline:
- Meniscal tear: a defect or split in the meniscus or where it joins the joint capsule, whether or not the meniscus is degenerative (its tissue progressively breaking down).
- Target, possible target and no target: how the tear looks on MRI. A target is a “treatable” lesion, for which the group agreed that surgery may be indicated on its appearance.
- Osteoarthritis: graded as early or none, mild or moderate, or advanced. Only advanced osteoarthritis was considered a major contraindication (a reason not to operate), so the recommendations were the same for everyone else.
What Did It Recommend?
The flow chart applies to a tear confirmed on MRI (the locked knee is the one exception) and has five common presentations:
- Locked knee. Urgent arthroscopic meniscal surgery was recommended. Clinicians could use their judgement on whether an MRI was needed first.
- Acute injury with a target tear on MRI. The recommendation was to consider arthroscopic meniscal repair, to preserve the meniscus, where the tear was repairable and the patient a suitable candidate. The urgency was left to the clinician, case by case, in careful consultation with the patient.
- Target tear on MRI with corresponding symptoms and signs. The group's assessment was that surgery may be beneficial after a trial of non-surgical treatment. Where symptoms had lasted more than three months, the recommendation was to consider non-urgent arthroscopic partial meniscectomy. Under three months, it was optimal non-operative treatment and reassessment. If earlier surgery seemed appropriate, the paper advised seeking a second opinion from an appropriately experienced colleague first.
- Possible target tear on MRI, or possibly meniscal symptoms and signs. Further non-surgical treatment was first line: a further three months was recommended at the first assessment in hospital care, followed by reassessment. The flow chart adds that surgery may be indicated in selected cases if symptoms do not improve.
- Advanced osteoarthritis with a meniscal tear, or arthritic symptoms and signs only. No arthroscopic meniscal surgery. The group judged it inappropriate in nearly all of these patients; in uncommon special circumstances, a second opinion was advised before going ahead. Such patients, the paper notes, may need assessment for other treatment, such as osteotomy (realigning the leg) or arthroplasty (joint replacement).
Non-surgical treatment, the group suggested, may include patient education, structured physiotherapy and, in some cases, a steroid injection into the knee. There was universal agreement that the patient's preferred form of treatment must always be considered. The guideline was to support shared decision making, not substitute for it. Clinical judgement was still required, especially where a patient does not fit clearly into one of the five presentations.
Why Does This Matter for Patients?
The three-month period was based on the clinical trials, in which most patients improved with structured physiotherapy. Up to 30% went on to partial meniscectomy because they had not improved, and they reportedly did improve after surgery. The group weighed that benefit against the risks, drawing on the national analysis that became my Lancet study of 700,000 procedures: the surgery was low-risk, but infection and pulmonary embolism (a blood clot in the lung), although rare, may be provoked by arthroscopy.
This page describes what was recommended for groups of patients. It is not advice for any one person. Which presentation someone has depends on their history, examination and scans, and the decision is made with them in clinic. My page on meniscal tears explains the condition and its treatments, and I have also summarised my 2019 article on the evidence behind the guideline.
What Could This Guideline Not Tell Us?
A consensus process delivers the best output it can from the evidence available at the time. As the paper puts it, this does not guarantee that the output is “correct”. We stated that the guideline needed validation in clinical practice, and modification if new evidence required it. This page describes the guideline as published in June 2019, and nothing that has appeared since.
The invited experts were all surgeons, and the paper acknowledges the potential criticism that surgeons who perform an operation often are more likely to recommend it. GPs, rheumatologists and physiotherapists may interpret the evidence differently, and the paper says more general guidance was planned, involving those groups, health commissioners and patients.
No trial had been carried out in patients with a locked knee, or limited to patients eligible for surgery under these standards, and no relevant high-level evidence was found on repair after an acute injury.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need surgery for a meniscal tear?
Not always. This guideline, published in 2019, recommended urgent keyhole surgery for a locked knee, and that repair be considered for a repairable tear after an acute injury. For most other patients it recommended at least three months of non-surgical treatment before surgery was considered. The decision for any one person is made in clinic.
How long should physiotherapy be tried before meniscal surgery is considered?
For most patients, the 2019 guideline recommended a minimum of three months of non-surgical treatment, which may include structured physiotherapy, before keyhole meniscal surgery was considered. Where the scan or the symptoms only possibly pointed to a treatable tear, a further three months was recommended at the first hospital assessment. There were two exceptions: urgent surgery was recommended for a locked knee, and repair was to be considered for a repairable tear after an acute injury.
Is keyhole surgery recommended for a meniscal tear in a knee with arthritis?
It depended on how advanced the arthritis was. The 2019 guideline did not recommend keyhole meniscal surgery for patients with advanced osteoarthritis, or with arthritic symptoms only, except in uncommon special cases where a second opinion was advised. Early, mild or moderate osteoarthritis did not change the recommendations.
What did the guideline recommend for a locked knee?
Urgent keyhole surgery. A locked knee is one that has become stuck and will not fully straighten or bend. No trial had been carried out in patients with a meniscal tear and a locked knee, so the recommendation reflected the high ratings that the working group gave to surgery.
Who wrote the BASK guideline on meniscal surgery?
I was the lead author. A working group of the British Association for Surgery of the Knee (BASK), made up of invited surgeons and a steering committee, rated 45 simulated patient scenarios for whether surgery was appropriate, discussed the results and rated them again. The draft then went to BASK members: 117 completed the survey, and 113 of them (97%) agreed to practise according to it.
Read the Full Paper
This paper is published open access in The Bone & Joint Journal under a Creative Commons licence (CC BY-NC). You can read the full text below, including the flow chart, or on the journal website or on PubMed Central.
Full citation: Abram SGF, Beard DJ, Price AJ; BASK Meniscal Working Group. Arthroscopic meniscal surgery: a national society treatment guideline and consensus statement. The Bone & Joint Journal. 2019;101-B(6):652–659. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.101B6.BJJ-2019-0126.R1
This summary is written for general information and explains the guideline in patient-friendly terms. It does not replace individual medical advice. If you have questions about a meniscal tear or your knee, please get in touch to arrange a consultation.