How Meniscal Tears Are Defined, Investigated and Classified: A National Consensus

The Knee · 2018 · Abram SGF, Beard DJ, Price AJ; BASK Meniscal Working Group

Key points

  • This consensus statement, published in The Knee in 2018, set out agreed definitions for the terms used to describe meniscal problems: what a tear is, which symptoms suggest one and how findings on MRI are classified.
  • It came from a national working group of surgeons convened by the British Association for Surgery of the Knee (BASK). All 47 definitions were agreed during 2017.
  • The group agreed that degenerative meniscal lesions are frequent in the general population and are often incidental findings on MRI rather than the cause of symptoms.
  • The paper defines terms. It does not say how they should be combined to decide who is offered an operation.

What Is This Consensus Statement?

Clinic letters and MRI reports about the meniscus, one of the two pads of cartilage in each knee, use terms such as degenerative tear, locking, bucket-handle tear and extrusion. This paper records what a national group of surgeons agreed such terms should mean.

It was written during a debate about arthroscopic partial meniscectomy, the keyhole operation to trim a torn meniscus. Trials of the operation were hard to interpret because patients had been selected on broad and inconsistent criteria. “Mechanical” symptoms were often highlighted as pointing to the meniscus, yet no definition of them had been agreed. In this project, I set out with my colleagues to agree standard terminology, so that patients with meniscal problems could be identified, described and compared consistently in clinical practice and research.

How Was Agreement Reached?

In November 2016 the committee of BASK approached 25 surgeons, and 21 agreed to join a working group alongside a steering committee of three, of which I was a member. We used nominal group techniques (structured meetings) and the Delphi process (anonymous questionnaires) in three phases.

Fifteen members met in February 2017 and refined the definitions by discussion and vote, with at least 80% (12 of 15) needed to agree. In May 2017, 19 of the 21 (90%) scored each definition from 1 (disagree) to 10 (agree) in an anonymous questionnaire. A mean of seven or more, with fewer than 20% of scores at four or less, counted as agreement. No further round of voting was needed, and 17 members met in November 2017 to agree the final version.

All 47 definitions were agreed. Thirty-four of them were in topics the group chose to sort into categories, which needed more than 50% of the votes. Thirty-two were placed at the first round; the other two were reviewed by the steering committee and approved at the final meeting.

What Was Agreed?

Degenerative meniscus and meniscal tear. A degenerative meniscus was defined as one that develops progressively, with degradation of the meniscal tissue; on MRI this may show as high signal (a bright area) within the meniscus. A meniscal tear was defined as a defect or split in the meniscus or where it joins the joint capsule, and can occur in a degenerative or a non-degenerative meniscus. Degenerative meniscal lesions (high signal or a tear) were agreed to be frequent in the general population and often incidental findings on a knee MRI (present without causing the symptoms), with or without a memorable injury.

Symptoms and signs. Each was defined and placed in one of three groups:

  • Strongly suggestive of a treatable meniscal lesion (highly likely to be meniscal in origin). Locked knee: a sudden, complete mechanical block to bending or straightening the knee, found on examination, that does not resolve despite adequate pain relief. Locking: an intermittent block to the normal range of movement, commonly to straightening, with an unlocking movement after which the knee returns to near normal. Catching: the sensation of something intermittently out of place in the knee and interfering with its movement. Tender, palpable meniscal tissue: a discrete, tender lump found on examination close to the joint line.
  • Potentially suggestive (possibly meniscal in origin). Episodic sharp pain, intermittent swelling, an effusion (fluid in the joint), avoidance of particular movements, squatting pain, clicking with or without pain, two kinds of joint line tenderness, and the McMurray's, Thessaly and Apley's examination tests.
  • Osteoarthritic (highly unlikely to be meniscal in origin). Pain and stiffness after inactivity, crepitus (crunching, grating or creaking), bony enlargement, bony tenderness and aching pain.

Investigation. In hospital clinics (secondary care), weight-bearing X-rays were agreed as the first-line investigation when osteoarthritis is suspected, and MRI when it is not. MRI is also indicated if X-rays do not show advanced osteoarthritis and meniscal symptoms predominate. Where clinical findings are conclusive, as with a locked knee, clinicians may judge whether MRI is needed.

Osteoarthritis. Its severity was graded as early or none, mild to moderate, or advanced to end-stage. On X-ray these are grades 0 or 1, 2 or 3, and 4 on the Kellgren–Lawrence scale; on MRI, no cartilage loss, partial-thickness loss, and significant areas of full-thickness loss (contained defects excepted).

Findings on MRI. Meniscal findings were classified by appearance as a target for meniscal surgery, a possible target or no target:

  • Target (a treatable lesion: meniscal surgery may be indicated based on appearance). Bucket-handle tear: a longitudinal (lengthwise) tear or peripheral separation (at the outer edge) involving more than 25% of the length of the meniscus, displaced or not. Displaced tear: fragments of meniscus moved from their usual position, which the paper calls definitively unstable. Meniscal root failure: a complete tear or avulsion (pulling away) of the meniscal root.
  • Possible target (an indeterminate lesion: meniscal surgery may be indicated based on appearance). Undisplaced tears: radial tears, horizontal cleavage tears with or without a meniscal cyst, complex lesions with more than one plane of tear, and short longitudinal tears involving less than 25% of the meniscus length.
  • No target (unlikely to be treatable: meniscal surgery not indicated based on appearance). An abnormal edge contour with only a very minor tear; isolated extrusion, where the meniscus extends beyond the edge of the shin bone without a tear; and no tear.

The group added a caution: movement of the knee may cause a tear to displace, so a report of a static MRI scan must be interpreted with care.

Why Does This Matter for Patients?

The paper's case for agreed terms starts from one observation: knee pain may be caused by osteoarthritis, and a meniscal tear may be an incidental finding. Our conclusion was that agreed definitions would allow patients with meniscal lesions to be identified and grouped consistently in clinical practice, research and guideline development. My page on meniscal tears explains the condition and its treatment.

What Could This Consensus Statement Not Tell Us?

This paper defines terms and sorts them into groups. It does not say how they should be combined to decide who is offered an operation. That came in the national treatment guideline on arthroscopic meniscal surgery published in 2019, for which this terminology was agreed first. My evidence update of the same year summarises new evidence on treatment.

We could not prove that the definitions cover everything, and a consensus cannot guarantee that its output is correct. The paper called for a period of validation, with changes if new evidence required them. The group was made up of surgeons. Other specialists, such as physiotherapists and rheumatologists, may have identified other items, changed the definitions or ranked them differently. And the definitions are those agreed in 2017: the paper cannot tell you whether the person who wrote your letter or scan report was using them.

Frequently asked questions

What does “degenerative meniscus” mean on an MRI report?

In this 2018 consensus statement, a degenerative meniscus was defined as one that develops progressively, with degradation of the meniscal tissue, which may show on MRI as high signal within the meniscus. A meniscal tear was defined separately, as a defect or split in the meniscus or where it joins the joint capsule, and can occur in a degenerative or a non-degenerative meniscus. The group agreed that degenerative meniscal lesions (high signal or a tear) are frequent in the general population and are often incidental findings on a knee MRI.

What do “locked knee”, “locking” and “catching” mean?

The consensus defined each one separately. A locked knee is a sudden, complete mechanical block to bending or straightening the knee, found on examination, that does not resolve despite adequate pain relief. Locking is an intermittent block to the normal range of movement, commonly to straightening, with an unlocking movement after which the knee returns to near normal. Catching is the sensation of something intermittently out of place in the knee and interfering with its movement. All three were classed as strongly suggestive of a treatable meniscal lesion.

What does “bucket-handle tear” mean?

In this consensus, a bucket-handle tear is a longitudinal tear (one running along the meniscus) or a peripheral separation (at its outer edge) involving more than 25% of the length of the meniscus, whether displaced or not. On MRI it was classed as a “target”, meaning a treatable lesion for which meniscal surgery may be indicated based on appearance. A longitudinal tear involving less than 25% of the meniscus length was called a short longitudinal tear and classed as a “possible target”.

What do “radial tear”, “horizontal cleavage tear” and “complex lesion” mean on an MRI report?

They are patterns of meniscal tear. In this consensus, a radial flap tear is a vertical and oblique tear, also called a parrot beak tear. A complete radial split tear extends to the junction between the meniscus and the joint capsule, and a partial radial split tear does not. A horizontal cleavage tear is a horizontal split in the meniscus, with or without a meniscal cyst. A complex meniscal lesion has more than one plane of tear in continuity. When undisplaced, all were classed as “possible targets”, meaning indeterminate lesions for which meniscal surgery may be indicated based on appearance.

Read the Full Paper

This paper is published open access in The Knee under a Creative Commons licence (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0). You can read the full text below, or on the journal website or in the Oxford University Research Archive.

Your browser does not support embedded PDFs. Download the PDF or view on the journal website.

Full citation: Abram SGF, Beard DJ, Price AJ; BASK Meniscal Working Group. National consensus on the definition, investigation, and classification of meniscal lesions of the knee. The Knee. 2018;25(5):834–840. doi:10.1016/j.knee.2018.06.001

This summary is written for general information and explains the consensus statement in patient-friendly terms. It does not replace individual medical advice. If you have questions about a meniscal tear or your knee, please get in touch to arrange a consultation.

← Back to Research, Guidelines & Articles