The Evidence Behind the 2019 National Guideline on Meniscal Surgery
Key points
- This short article, published in The Knee in 2019, summarised the research produced to support a national guideline on keyhole meniscal surgery.
- No trial had been performed in patients with an unstable tear on a scan and symptoms to match, nor in patients who had not improved with physiotherapy.
- The guideline advised at least 3 months of non-operative treatment first for most patients.
- Findings are given here as the article stated them in 2019.
What Is This Article?
Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy is a keyhole operation to trim a torn meniscus, one of the cartilage pads that cushion the knee. In 2019 the Meniscal Working Group of the British Association for Surgery of the Knee (BASK) published a national guideline on when meniscal surgery is appropriate. I was its first author.
The guideline followed more than two years of work supported by BASK, the NHS Getting It Right First Time programme and the National Institute for Health Research. In this article I summarised the new evidence from that programme.
What Evidence Did It Summarise?
The trials and the guideline are covered below. The other work was:
- Rates of surgery. An analysis of keyhole knee surgery in England from 1997 to 2017 found that partial meniscectomy rates had increased by 130% over 20 years, with a partial decline since 2013 (likely in response to new clinical trial evidence) and a high level of variation between regions.
- Knee replacement within a year. A second national analysis found that 10% of patients over 60 who had a partial meniscectomy had a knee replacement within one year. The rate of knee replacement varied more than 10-fold between regions.
- Risks. In my Lancet study of 700,000 operations, at least one serious complication occurred in 0.3% of patients within 90 days. A blood clot in the lung (pulmonary embolism) and knee joint infection were seen at a higher rate than in the general population, corresponding to one attributable pulmonary embolism and two infections for every 1,500 operations. There was no attributable risk of death, heart attack or stroke.
- Agreed terms. A consensus published in The Knee in 2018 agreed standardised terminology, which had not existed before. Symptoms were classified as strongly suggestive of a treatable meniscal lesion (such as a tear), potentially suggestive of one, or osteoarthritic, and MRI findings as a target for treatment, a possible target or no target.
What Did It Say About the Trial Evidence?
The correct interpretation of the randomised trials of partial meniscectomy had been controversial, and developing the guideline required a new systematic review of them, published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine.
The article called one finding perhaps the most important: no trial had been performed, or registered, in patients with an unstable meniscal tear confirmed on a scan and symptoms to match, nor in patients who had not improved after a period of appropriate physiotherapy. The published trials had all applied relatively non-specific selection criteria: knee pain and any pattern of meniscal tear.
Even so, the benefit of surgery over physiotherapy at 6 to 12 months (in pain, function and knee-specific quality of life) was greater in patients without osteoarthritis than in those with it. In the trials against physiotherapy, up to 30% of patients later chose to have the operation. The article said this made the trials' analyses harder to interpret, but suggested that non-operative treatment first “may be appropriate for the majority of these patients”.
What Did the Guideline Recommend?
The article summarised the guideline as recommending that:
- arthroscopic (keyhole) meniscal surgery should not be performed in patients with advanced osteoarthritis, except in rare special cases;
- most patients presenting with a meniscal tear and symptoms should first have at least 3 months of non-operative treatment;
- for those who do not respond, meniscal surgery may be beneficial and should be considered;
- urgent surgery may be indicated for a locked knee (one that has become stuck and will not fully straighten or bend), and repair should be considered for a repairable tear after an acute injury.
When BASK members were consulted, 97% of respondents agreed to practise according to the recommendations.
What Was Still Unknown in 2019?
Besides the gaps in the trials, the article reported that questionnaires used to record pain, function and quality of life (patient-reported outcome measures) had only poor-quality, incomplete evidence of validity in patients with meniscal tears. The smallest change in score that matters to these patients was unknown. The article said the guideline now required adoption and validation in clinical practice.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need surgery straight away for a meniscal tear?
The national guideline summarised in this 2019 article advised that most patients with a meniscal tear and symptoms should first have at least 3 months of non-operative treatment. For patients who did not respond, it said that meniscal surgery may be beneficial and should be considered. It also said that urgent surgery may be indicated for a locked knee.
Is keyhole surgery better than physiotherapy for a meniscal tear?
This 2019 article reported that, in the randomised trials published by then, a greater benefit from partial meniscectomy over physiotherapy was found at 6 to 12 months in patients without osteoarthritis than in patients with it. No trial had been performed in patients with an unstable tear confirmed on a scan and symptoms to match, nor in patients who had not improved after a period of appropriate physiotherapy.
How risky is keyhole surgery for a torn meniscus?
This article, from 2019, described the risk as low. It cites my study of 700,000 partial meniscectomy operations in England, in which at least one serious complication occurred in 0.3% of patients within 90 days. A blood clot in the lung (pulmonary embolism) and knee joint infection were seen more often than in the general population, corresponding to one attributable pulmonary embolism and two infections for every 1,500 operations.
Read the Full Paper
This article is published in The Knee, and the final version is on the journal website. The accepted manuscript is free to read in the Oxford University Research Archive.
Full citation: Abram SGF, Beard DJ, Hing CB, Price AJ. Evidence update: A summary of new evidence to inform treatment decisions for patients with meniscal lesions. The Knee. 2019;26(3):521–523. doi:10.1016/j.knee.2019.04.017
This summary is written for general information and explains the article in patient-friendly terms. It does not replace individual medical advice. If you have questions about a meniscal tear or your knee, please get in touch to arrange a consultation.