Fixed or Adjustable Loop for ACL Graft Fixation? One-Year Results of the GAP Randomised Trial

Journal of ISAKOS · 2026 · Abram SGF, Nelson A, Middleton S, Mandalia V

Key points

  • This randomised, double-blinded trial compared two ways of holding a hamstring graft in the thigh bone during ACL reconstruction: a fixed-length loop and an adjustable-length loop.
  • Knee laxity (how far the shin bone moves forwards under a set force) at one year was 4.99 mm with the fixed loop and 5.09 mm with the adjustable loop at 134 N, not a statistically significant difference (P = 0.69).
  • Patient-reported scores were not significantly different at 6 or 12 months.
  • Across both groups, the operated knee was 1.11 mm more lax than the other knee at one year (at 134 N).
  • Of 164 patients randomised, 121 (74%) had complete laxity measurements at one year. The trial was sized to compare laxity, not graft failure or revision rates.

What Was This Study About?

In an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, the new ligament (the graft) has to be held firmly in the bone while it heals. In the thigh bone (femur), the method most commonly used in the UK, according to the National Ligament Registry report cited in the paper, is suspensory fixation, in which the graft is suspended in the bone tunnel from a loop. The loop has commonly been of fixed length. Adjustable-length loops were developed more recently, with the theoretical advantages of more precise graft placement and less stock held in theatre.

The concern has been slippage: that an adjustable loop might lengthen under repeated loading and leave the knee looser. Industry-supported laboratory studies had been encouraging, but such tests cannot fully reproduce a living knee, and the earlier clinical studies comparing the two were small and mostly not randomised.

In this study, my colleagues and I compared the two kinds of loop in a randomised controlled trial, the GAP study (ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03184922). It was conceived and designed by the senior author, Vipul Mandalia, and patients were recruited at the Princess Elizabeth Orthopaedic Centre in Exeter. My part was to analyse the data and write the paper.

Between August 2017 and August 2022, 164 patients were randomly allocated, 82 to each group. All had a graft from their own hamstring tendons, and two consultant surgeons performed the operations. The graft was fixed in the femur with either a fixed-length loop (G-Lok) or an adjustable-length loop (ProCinch), both made by Stryker. Fixation in the shin bone (tibia), with an interference screw, and the post-operative protocols were the same in both groups. Neither the patients nor the physiotherapist who took the measurements knew which loop had been used.

The primary outcome was knee laxity one year after surgery, measured by a machine (an arthrometer) at a force of 134 newtons (N). Laxity was also measured at 3 and 6 months, and at 150 N (6 and 12 months) and 200 N (12 months). Both knees were tested, so that the uninjured knee could act as a control. Patients completed questionnaires (the Tegner, KOOS, IKDC and Lysholm scores) at baseline, 6 and 12 months.

The size of the trial was calculated for laxity. There is no agreed smallest difference in laxity that matters, so a threshold of 3.6 mm between knees was selected, 0.6 mm above the 3.0 mm taken as the upper limit of a satisfactory result. With 90% power, that required 60 patients in each group. Recruitment was increased to 164 after COVID-19 restrictions affected follow-up.

What Did We Find?

At one year, 121 of the 164 patients (74%) had complete laxity measurements: 58 in the fixed-loop group and 63 in the adjustable-loop group. Their average age was 31 and 62% were male.

Laxity. There was no statistically significant difference between the groups at 3 months, 6 months or one year, at any force (the threshold for significance was P below 0.05). At one year, average laxity of the operated knee, with its 95% confidence interval, was:

  • at 134 N, the primary outcome: 4.99 mm (4.62 to 5.36) with the fixed loop and 5.09 mm (4.74 to 5.44) with the adjustable loop, P = 0.69
  • at 150 N: 5.51 mm (5.13 to 5.87) and 5.61 mm (5.26 to 5.96), P = 0.68
  • at 200 N: 6.94 mm (6.53 to 7.34) and 7.02 mm (6.63 to 7.40), P = 0.78

The same was true of the difference between the two knees:

  • at 134 N: 1.20 mm (0.89 to 1.51) with the fixed loop and 1.04 mm (0.68 to 1.39) with the adjustable loop, P = 0.50
  • at 150 N: 1.23 mm (0.93 to 1.52) and 1.00 mm (0.64 to 1.36), P = 0.33
  • at 200 N: 1.26 mm (0.93 to 1.58) and 0.99 mm (0.61 to 1.37), P = 0.29

Patient-reported scores. Scores improved in both groups, with no statistically significant difference between them at 6 or 12 months. At 12 months, the averages for the fixed and adjustable loops were:

  • Tegner activity level: 4.80 and 5.16, P = 0.297
  • KOOS Symptoms: 79.59 and 83.48, P = 0.127
  • KOOS Pain: 87.63 and 90.38, P = 0.158
  • KOOS Activities of Daily Living: 94.35 and 96.36, P = 0.129
  • KOOS Sport: 79.20 and 79.69, P = 0.880
  • KOOS Quality of Life: 62.61 and 67.30, P = 0.204
  • IKDC: 77.87 and 80.78, P = 0.289
  • Lysholm: 86.04 and 88.95, P = 0.128

Return to activity. At 12 months, 30 of 107 patients (28%) had returned to their pre-injury Tegner activity level and 56 of 107 (52%) were within one level of it, with no significant difference between the groups. Rehabilitation after ACL reconstruction is covered on my return to sport page.

Reference data. Across both groups, the operated knee was more lax than the uninjured knee at every visit: at one year, by 1.11 mm at 134 N (95% confidence interval 0.88 to 1.34), 5.04 mm against 3.93 mm. The paper offers these figures as reference data for hamstring ACL reconstruction.

Graft failure. One patient, in the adjustable-loop group, had a graft failure after a twisting injury during rehabilitation at four months. X-rays showed an increased posterior tibial slope (the top of the shin bone tilting backwards), which was managed with an osteotomy (an operation to realign the bone). The patient opted not to have revision ACL surgery, withdrew from the trial and is not included in the analyses. The paper describes no other adverse events.

Why Does This Matter for Patients?

This trial looked directly for the slippage that had been the worry with adjustable loops, by measuring laxity. One year after a hamstring ACL reconstruction, it found no statistically significant difference between the two kinds of loop in laxity or in patient-reported scores, as in earlier clinical studies. It does not show that one loop is better than the other.

What Could This Study Not Tell Us?

The trial followed patients for one year, the period over which the graft would be expected to become incorporated. It was not designed for long-term outcomes such as revision surgery, which the paper puts at around 3% within five years, citing my national study of complications and revision. Nor can one graft failure among 164 patients show whether the loops differ in that respect.

Follow-up was incomplete, so the potential for bias cannot be completely excluded. The 43 patients without complete one-year measurements were younger on average (26.6 years against 31.2, P = 0.008), which may limit how far the findings apply to younger patients. They did not differ significantly in sex, other procedures or allocated loop (P = 0.375).

This was a single-centre trial with two surgeons, one graft type (hamstring) and one method of tibial fixation. The results may not apply to other graft types, fixation constructs or surgical techniques.

Frequently asked questions

Does it matter whether a fixed or adjustable loop is used to fix an ACL graft?

In this randomised, double-blinded trial of 164 patients having a hamstring ACL reconstruction, there was no statistically significant difference at one year between a fixed-length loop and an adjustable-length loop, either in knee laxity or in any patient-reported score. The trial followed patients for one year and was sized to compare laxity, not graft failure or revision rates.

Do adjustable loops slip or loosen after ACL reconstruction?

Slippage of adjustable loops under repeated loading was the concern behind this trial, so knee laxity was the primary outcome. One year after surgery, laxity of the operated knee at 134 N averaged 4.99 mm with the fixed loop and 5.09 mm with the adjustable loop (P = 0.69), and the difference from the other knee was 1.20 mm and 1.04 mm (P = 0.50). Neither difference was statistically significant.

What is suspensory fixation in ACL reconstruction?

It is a method of fixing an ACL graft in which the graft is suspended in the bone tunnel from a loop, which may be of fixed or adjustable length. In this trial it was used in the thigh bone (femur). According to the National Ligament Registry report cited in the paper, it is the most commonly used method of femoral fixation in the UK, at 77% of cases, followed by interference screw fixation at 17%.

How much looser is the knee after ACL reconstruction than the other knee?

In this trial, taking both groups together, the operated knee was on average 1.11 mm more lax than the uninjured knee one year after a hamstring ACL reconstruction, when tested at 134 N (5.04 mm against 3.93 mm). The trial had defined failure in advance as a difference of more than 3 mm between knees, or an absolute laxity of more than 10 mm.

How many people are back to their previous activity level a year after ACL reconstruction?

In this trial, 30 of 107 patients (28%) had returned to their pre-injury Tegner activity level at 12 months, and 56 of 107 (52%) were within one level of it. There was no statistically significant difference between the fixed-loop and adjustable-loop groups.

Read the Full Paper

This paper is published open access in the Journal of ISAKOS under a Creative Commons licence (CC BY-NC-ND). You can read the full text below, or on the journal website.

Your browser does not support embedded PDFs. Download the PDF or view on the journal website.

Full citation: Abram SGF, Nelson A, Middleton S, Mandalia V. No differences in objective knee laxity measurements or patient-reported outcome measures between fixed- and adjustable-loop suspensory fixation in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: 1-year results from the GAP study, a prospective, double-blinded, randomized trial. Journal of ISAKOS. 2026;18:101123. doi:10.1016/j.jisako.2026.101123

This summary is written for general information and explains the research in patient-friendly terms. It does not replace individual medical advice. If you have questions about an ACL injury or your knee, please get in touch to arrange a consultation.

← Back to Research, Guidelines & Articles