How Safe Is ACL Reconstruction? Complication and Revision Rates in 104,255 Operations
Key points
- This study used NHS hospital records for ACL reconstructions performed in England over 20 years (1997 to 2017): 104,255 operations.
- Serious complications within 90 days were uncommon, occurring after 0.65% of operations (around 1 in 150).
- The most frequent were infection needing a further operation (0.47%, around 1 in 200) and a blood clot in the lung, known as a pulmonary embolism (0.12%, around 1 in 800).
- Within five years, 3.2% of patients had a revision ACL reconstruction in the same knee and 2.9% had an ACL reconstruction in the opposite knee.
- Younger patients were more likely to need a revision, and the overall risk of serious complications fell over the 20 years studied.
What Was This Study About?
Reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is an elective operation: after an ACL injury, some people do well with rehabilitation alone, while others choose surgery to restore stability. To make that choice properly, patients need to know the real risks as well as the expected benefits. Before this study, those risks had been estimated from small studies, often from single hospitals, with concerns about how completely complications had been recorded.
In this study, I set out to measure those risks as reliably as possible. With my colleagues at the University of Oxford, I analysed the national Hospital Episode Statistics database, which records NHS-funded operations across England, linked to national death records. Between April 1997 and March 2017 there were 133,270 ACL reconstructions. After excluding revision operations, patients who had both knees operated on within six months, and those who had cartilage or multiple-ligament surgery at the same time, 104,255 first-time ACL reconstructions remained for analysis. The average age was 29, and just under a quarter of patients were women.
The main question was how often at least one serious complication occurred within 90 days of surgery. I defined a serious complication as a heart attack, stroke, pulmonary embolism, infection requiring further surgery, fasciotomy (an emergency operation to relieve pressure in the leg), nerve or blood vessel injury, or death. I also looked at how many patients went on to further surgery within five years, and compared the complication rates with those expected in people of the same age and sex in the general population.
What Did We Find?
Serious complications were uncommon. Within 90 days, 675 of the 104,255 operations (0.65%) were followed by at least one serious complication. The two that accounted for most of these were:
- Infection needing a further operation to wash out the knee: 494 cases (0.47%).
- Pulmonary embolism (a blood clot in the lung): 129 cases (0.12%). None of these was fatal.
Other serious complications were rare. Nerve or blood vessel injury and fasciotomy each occurred after about 0.02% of operations (fewer than 1 in 5,000). Death within 90 days was recorded after 14 operations (0.01%), which is lower than expected for people of the same age in the general population, as were the rates of heart attack and stroke. This most likely reflects the fact that people having ACL surgery are, on the whole, young and healthy.
Two risks were clearly higher than in the general population: pulmonary embolism and knee joint infection. From the comparison, I estimated that for every 850 ACL reconstructions performed, about one pulmonary embolism and four knee infections occur that would not otherwise have happened.
Some patients were at higher risk. The chance of a serious complication rose with age and was higher in people with other medical conditions. It was lower in women than in men. Encouragingly, the overall risk fell gradually over the 20 years studied.
Further surgery within five years. Among the 54,275 operations with at least five years of follow-up:
- 3.2% were followed by a revision ACL reconstruction in the same knee.
- 2.9% of patients had an ACL reconstruction in the opposite knee.
- 0.6% had further meniscal surgery in the same knee.
Age made a clear difference to the chance of revision. Patients under 20 were about 1.75 times as likely to have a revision as those aged 20 to 39, while those aged 40 to 59 were about half as likely. Women were less likely than men to have a revision or further meniscal surgery, but just as likely to need a reconstruction in the opposite knee.
Why Does This Matter for Patients?
Because ACL reconstruction is a choice rather than a necessity, honest figures matter. This study gives them: the operation is safe for the great majority of people, but it is not risk-free, and the two risks worth discussing before surgery are infection and blood clots.
One of the more interesting findings was that the chance of a further ACL reconstruction was almost the same in the operated knee as in the opposite, previously uninjured knee. That suggests the reconstructed ligament and the natural ligament in the other knee are at a comparable risk of rupture afterwards. It underlines the importance of thorough rehabilitation and a careful, criteria-based return to sport, especially for younger patients, in whom revision was most common.
The complication rate was around twice that seen after keyhole meniscus surgery in my earlier study of 700,000 procedures (0.65% compared with 0.32%). That is not surprising, as ACL reconstruction is a longer and more involved operation, but it is a useful reminder that the decision to operate should be weighed against the alternative of rehabilitation first.
What Could This Study Not Tell Us?
Hospital records of this kind have limits. They do not record the type of graft or the surgical technique used, or factors such as body weight and smoking, so the study cannot say how these affect risk. Infections treated with antibiotics alone were not captured, only those needing further surgery. And because the database covers NHS-funded care, a revision carried out privately would not have been counted, so the five-year figures for further surgery are, if anything, underestimates. They also count operations rather than injuries: not everyone who re-injures an ACL goes on to have another reconstruction.
Frequently asked questions
How common are serious complications after ACL reconstruction?
Uncommon. In this study of 104,255 ACL reconstructions in England, 0.65% of operations (around 1 in 150) were followed by a serious complication within 90 days. Serious complications were defined as a heart attack, stroke, blood clot in the lung, infection needing further surgery, fasciotomy, nerve or blood vessel injury, or death.
What is the risk of infection after ACL reconstruction?
In this study, 0.47% of patients (around 1 in 200) needed a further operation for infection within 90 days of their ACL reconstruction. Infections treated with antibiotics alone were not captured, so the figure describes infections serious enough to need surgery.
What is the risk of a blood clot in the lung (pulmonary embolism) after ACL reconstruction?
A pulmonary embolism occurred after 0.12% of operations (around 1 in 800) within 90 days. None of these was fatal in this study. Compared with people of the same age and sex in the general population, this works out at roughly one additional pulmonary embolism for every 850 ACL reconstructions performed.
How likely am I to need a revision ACL reconstruction?
Among patients followed for at least five years, 3.2% had a revision ACL reconstruction in the same knee within five years. The risk was higher in younger patients: those under 20 were about 1.75 times as likely to have a revision as those aged 20 to 39.
How likely am I to need an ACL reconstruction in my other knee?
Within five years, 2.9% of patients had an ACL reconstruction in the opposite knee, which is very similar to the 3.2% who had a revision in the same knee. These figures count further operations, so the true rate of re-injury will be higher, because not everyone who injures an ACL has surgery.
Read the Full Paper
This paper is published in the American Journal of Sports Medicine, where the final version is available to subscribers on the journal website. The accepted manuscript is free to read through the University of Bristol research repository and the Oxford University Research Archive.
Full citation: Abram SGF, Judge A, Beard DJ, Price AJ. Rates of Adverse Outcomes and Revision Surgery After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Study of 104,255 Procedures Using the National Hospital Episode Statistics Database for England, UK. American Journal of Sports Medicine. 2019;47(11):2533–2542. doi:10.1177/0363546519861393
This summary is written for general information and explains the research in patient-friendly terms. It does not replace individual medical advice. If you have questions about an ACL injury or your knee, please get in touch to arrange a consultation.