What Patients Believe About Meniscal Tears, and How It Shapes Treatment Decisions

European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology · 2022 · Ahmed I, Dhaif F, Abram SGF, Parsons N, Hutchinson C, Price A, Staniszewska S, Metcalfe A

Key points

  • I was a co-author of this review, which searched for studies asking people with a meniscal tear about their experiences and expectations. Only two were found, with 34 participants between them.
  • Participants often saw the MRI findings as a source of their pain.
  • Surgery was perceived to be the definitive and quicker approach, and physiotherapy as slower, though many who persisted with it described their symptoms improving.
  • The effect on daily life, and each person's way of making decisions, also influenced the choice of treatment.
  • These are themes from two small studies, not measures of how common each view is.

What Was This Study About?

A meniscal tear can be treated with or without an operation. In the decade before this paper, research found that surgery may be no more effective than physiotherapy for many patients. In response, UK and European guidelines recommended a period of non-operative treatment before surgery is considered, unless the knee is acutely locked. As the paper notes, patients were not involved in developing those guidelines, and very little had been published on how patients themselves experience a meniscal tear.

This study, which I contributed to, was a systematic review of qualitative research: studies that record people's views in their own words and do not count how often something happens. The research team searched several major research databases on 9 November 2020. Of the 3,552 articles identified, only two studies were eligible.

Both were published in 2020 and used semi-structured interviews with patients seen in specialist clinics. One, from Ireland, involved 10 people aged 35 to 65 with degenerative (age-related) tears. The other, from the USA, involved 24 people aged 18 to 50 with acute tears in knees without arthritis. Two members of the team appraised each study against a standard checklist and grouped what was said into new themes.

What Did We Find?

Five themes came out of the two studies. They describe what the people interviewed said, and will not hold for everyone with a meniscal tear.

MRI results were a key driver of decisions. Participants often referred to the MRI findings as a source of their pain. One said the scan showed “the meniscus is busted”. A keen cyclist decided to stay off the bike once the result came back.

Surgery was perceived to be the definitive and quicker approach. The belief was that symptoms would not resolve without an operation. One participant was “willing to take the risk for a definitive fix”.

Physiotherapy and exercise were a slower approach that brought success over time. Opinions were mixed. Some felt physiotherapy was “pushing off the problem”. Many who persisted described their symptoms improving, and one, after six months building up the muscle around the knee, found the physiotherapy “amazing altogether”.

Patients' perceptions and decision-making preferences were an important part of the consultation. One participant described being “fairly aggressive” when making decisions. Some preferred to watch and wait, or would “rather not get cut open if I don't need to”. Practical matters such as time off work and being on crutches came into it as well.

The impact on patients' lives was an important driver in seeking care. Participants described worrying daily about the knee locking and being unable to do anything active. One said: “The pain was so bad I wasn't able to live my life.” There was also a belief that the knee would only get worse with time.

Why Does This Matter for Patients?

Some of these beliefs do not match the wider evidence. A tear seen on a scan is not always the cause of the pain: the paper cites earlier research in which up to 61% of people with a meniscal tear had no symptoms. We recommended that MRI results are discussed clearly with patients, including which findings are relevant to the treatment decision and which may be unrelated to the symptoms.

Nor is surgery always the definitive treatment. Reviews of randomised trials had found that, for many patients with knee pain and a meniscal tear, there may be little difference in outcome between surgery and physiotherapy, with any benefit of surgery no longer present one to two years afterwards. The operation also carries some risk. The paper quotes figures from my study of around 700,000 keyhole meniscus operations: 0.3% of patients had a serious complication within 90 days, and 0.08% a blood clot in the lung (pulmonary embolism).

One belief did fit the evidence. The participants' experience of physiotherapy as slower but successful over time is in keeping with trial evidence that it is effective in the longer term.

Because there may not be one clear best treatment, we concluded that clinicians should work with each patient towards a shared decision, taking account of symptoms and examination findings as well as the scan, and of how much input that person wants.

What Could This Study Not Tell Us?

The main limitation is how little research there was to review: two studies, one of which had features of a high risk of bias. Both interviewed people seen in specialist clinics, and the authors of the Irish study acknowledged that views there may not carry over to primary care, such as general practice.

The quotes published in both studies were very short, possibly because the interviewers asked largely closed questions, which made it difficult to generate new themes. The American study did not discuss the relationship between interviewer and patients or describe checking its findings with participants, and its interview guide was not available. With so little data, we did not tie the review to a particular theoretical framework.

A review of this kind describes beliefs and experiences. It does not test which treatment works better, and it cannot say how common any view is. We recommended further qualitative studies using open-ended questions, in men and women across a range of ages having surgical and non-surgical treatment.

Frequently asked questions

Does a meniscal tear on an MRI scan mean I need surgery?

Not necessarily. In the two interview studies covered by this review, people often referred to the MRI findings as a source of their pain. The paper cites research in which up to 61% of people with a meniscal tear had no symptoms, and notes that UK and European guidelines recommend a period of non-operative treatment before surgery is considered, unless the knee is acutely locked.

Is surgery better than physiotherapy for a meniscal tear?

This review did not compare treatments. It examined what patients believe about them, and found that surgery was perceived to be the definitive and quicker approach. The paper refers to reviews of randomised trials which found that, for many patients with knee pain and a meniscal tear, there may be little difference in outcome between surgery and physiotherapy, with any benefit of surgery no longer present one to two years afterwards.

Can a meniscal tear get better without surgery?

In the interview studies this review brought together, some people believed their knee would not get better without an operation. Others described their symptoms improving with physiotherapy and exercise, although it took time. The paper notes that this is in keeping with trial evidence that physiotherapy is effective in the longer term. The review recorded what patients said and did not measure recovery.

How does a meniscal tear affect daily life?

The 34 people interviewed for the two studies in this review had all been seen in specialist clinics. Some described worrying every day about the knee locking, or being unable to do anything active. Others said they had learned to live with it, or that the pain had largely gone away. These accounts come from a small group and do not describe everyone with a meniscal tear.

Read the Full Paper

This paper is published open access in the European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology under a Creative Commons licence (CC BY 4.0). You can read the full text below, or on the journal website or on PubMed Central.

Your browser does not support embedded PDFs. Download the PDF or view on the journal website.

Full citation: Ahmed I, Dhaif F, Abram SGF, Parsons N, Hutchinson C, Price A, Staniszewska S, Metcalfe A. Patient beliefs and perceptions play a crucial role in the decision-making process when managing a meniscal tear. A qualitative systematic review of the literature. European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology. 2022;32(4):619–630. doi:10.1007/s00590-021-03019-8

This summary is written for general information and explains the research in patient-friendly terms. It does not replace individual medical advice. If you have questions about a meniscal tear or your knee, please get in touch to arrange a consultation.

← Back to Research, Guidelines & Articles